Skip to content

Outstanding Key Lime Pies in Miami

Blue Collar
Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop
Juvia Miami
Yardbird Southern Table & Bar
Stiltsville Fish Bar
OLA Restaurant
A Fish Called Avalon
Blue Collar
Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop
Juvia Miami
Yardbird Southern Table & Bar
Stiltsville Fish Bar
OLA Restaurant
A Fish Called Avalon

The famous Key Lime Pie, whose origin is the Florida Keys, is a favorite for many. And the good thing is, you don’t have to plan an entire trip down to Key West to get a test of the dessert, while you can get it right here in Miami. Although several joints make perfect Key Lime Pies in Miami, here’s a list of a few of our favorites.

 


Photo credit: Yelp

Blue Collar

6730 Biscayne BLVD, Miami, FL 22138
(305) 756 0366

Blue Collar is a small restaurant located in the MIMO district of Miami. And their Key Lime Pie has an extra thrill because it’s homemade by Meghan Perkins, wife to Billy Corben – director of Cocaine Cowboys. One of the best things about their key lime pie is that it tastes and feels very traditional, with a tangy feeling and some whipped cream. While you are at Blue Collar, you might consider trying their creamy mac n’ cheese for a complete experience.

 


Photo credit: Yelp

Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop

2545 N Miami Ave BAY I, Miami, FL 33127
(786) 703-3623

Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop is a family-owned bakery in Miami, best known for its state-of-the-art dessert and pies, among them key lime pies. Everything at Fireman Derek’s is baked in-house, using fresh, locally-sourced ingredients. For instance, their custard is made from hand-squeezed key limes to create the ultimate homemade pie experience. You will also appreciate the mastery of balance between sweet and tart – which is no surprise, given they have been making pies for the last two decades. And you can take some home.

 


Photo credit: usarestaurants.info

Icebox Café

1855 Purdy Avenue Miami Beach, FL, 33139
(305) 538-8448

The Ice Box café is well known for its award-winning dessert line, uniquely created by owner Robert Siegmann. Its outstanding performance has seen Ice Box Café make multiple media appearances, including The Oprah Winfrey Show. At Ice Box, all Key Lime Pies are made from scratch using the finest ingredients you can put your hands on. Even better, the custard is topped with just the perfect amount of whipped cream. Even better, Ice Box can accommodate you even if you’d like to host a large party or event.

 


Photo credit: Instagram

Juvia Miami

1111 Lincoln RD, Miami Beach, FL 33139
(305) 763-8272

Juvia Miami gets its name from the indigenous Brazilian nut tree, Juvia. And even before you indulge in their famous key lime pies, you get to enjoy the view from the rooftop of the Herzog & de Meuron 1111 Lincoln Road building. Although their key lime pie might not be the most traditional one around, it still packs flavor worth your while and is equally a work of art.

 


Photo credit: Twitter

Yardbird Southern Table & Bar

1600 Lennox Avenue, Miami Beach, FL33139
(305) 538 5220

Yardbird Southern Table & Bar is a household name when it comes to comfort food and a wide range of American classics. And one thing about Yardbird Southern Table & Bar’s key lime pie is the perfect balance between sweet and tangy. It’s the ideal way to end a meal of mac n’ cheese and fried chicken. Besides, if you’d like to enjoy your key lime pie from home, you can order pick up or have your pie delivered right at your doorstep.

 


Photo credit: fineschmeckers.ca

Stiltsville Fish Bar

1787 Purdy Avenue, Miami Beach, FL 33139
(786) 724 -1671

If you are looking for a perfect and sweet way to end your meal, we encourage you to try the coconut key lime pie at Stiltsville Fish Bar. Like everything else on their menu, their key lime pie is worth all the hype – made with a graham cracker and coconut crust guaranteeing you sweetness to the last bite. And lucky for you, they remain open Monday through Sunday.

 


Photo credit: Yelp

OLA Restaurant

2360 Collins Ave. Miami Beach, FL 33139
(305) 695-9125

OLA is an award-winning restaurant in Miami Beach, known for flavors of Latin America, and serves one of the best key lime pies you’ll ever have. Another thing we love about OLA restaurant, besides the bold flavors, is the rooftop dining option, where you can hold a private party and enjoy a good time with a large group of friends. Besides, all the ingredients are handpicked, so quality is a guarantee.

 


Photo credit: afishcalledavalon.com

A Fish Called Avalon

700 Ocean Drive, Miami Beach, FL 33139
(305) 532-1727

For the last three decades, A Fish Called Avalon has been relentless in ensuring that locals and visitors alike get the best dining experience in South Florida. And we can say without fear of contradiction that it has been mission accomplished, with success stories like the 2019 national pie champion – pecan-crusted key lime pie. But besides the award-winning key lime pies, you can also indulge in other delicacies, from carefully prepared appetizers to seafood, to cocktails, and do much more. The music here is also a whole experience worth trying out.